What would Jesus do?

Some people ask themselves "what would Jesus do?" in certain situations. I've thought about this and it seems like there are two main approaches one can take.

Approach 1: what would Jesus do 'as-he-was-back-then'. With all the biases and culture from those times. He'd likely be pretty conservative for today's standards.
Approach 2: what would Jesus do 'as-he-would-be-today'. This approach considers the difference between the prevailing culture at the time Jesus lived and Jesus's own personal views, and then apply that difference to today's prevailing culture. I strongly suspect he'd be some sort of hippie, or at the very least give strong hippie-like 'peace and love' vibes.

More detailed analysis may be coming if I feel like it.